Sunday, May 07, 2006

Bruce Chatwin or Tom Pepper?

Following on from yesterday's post, more on the veracity of BC's work: -

From The wiki of Bruce Chatwin : -

He spent six months there, (patagonia) a trip which resulted in the book In Patagonia (1977), which established his reputation as a travel writer. Later, however, residents in the region came forward to contradict the events that were depicted in Chatwin's book. It was the first, but not the last time in his career, that conversations and characters that Chatwin reported as true, were alleged to be just fiction

and: -

Chatwin is admired for his spare, lapidary style and his innate story-telling abilities. However, he has also been strongly criticized for his fictionalized anecdotes of real people, places, and events. Frequently, the people he wrote about recognized themselves and did not always appreciate his distortions of their culture and behaviour. Chatwin, however, was philosophical about what he saw as an unavoidable dilemma, arguing that his portrayals were not intended to be faithful representations; as Nicholas Shakespeare, his biographer, argues: 'He tells not a half truth, but a truth and a half.'


P.S. I can't be bothered to put stuff in small font any more

0 Comments:

Post a Comment

<< Home